The Lion and the Unicorn: The Real Story Behind the Nursery Rhyme
- , by Jessica Miller
- 12 min reading time
The nursery rhyme about the lion and the unicorn hides centuries of Anglo-Scottish conflict, from the Wars of Independence to the Union of the Crowns in 1603. Discover the real history behind the rhyme, the chained unicorn on the Royal Coat of Arms, and Lewis Carroll's satirical retelling.
Most people hear "the lion and the unicorn" and think of a cute nursery rhyme. Something you'd sing to a toddler. Maybe involving drums and plum cake. And sure, that version exists. But the real story behind those words? It's a centuries-old grudge match between two entire nations, a power struggle over crowns, and one of the most enduring rivalries in British history.
The lion is England. The unicorn is Scotland. And they were fighting long before anyone set them to music.
Let's start with the rhyme itself, because even the words are stranger than you remember.
The Nursery Rhyme Everyone Misremembers
Here's how most versions of the rhyme go:
The lion and the unicorn were fighting for the crown,
The lion beat the unicorn all around the town.
Some gave them white bread, and some gave them brown;
Some gave them plum cake and drummed them out of town.
On the surface, it's nonsense. Why are a lion and a unicorn having a street fight? Who's handing out bread during a brawl? And what does plum cake have to do with anything?
But nursery rhymes in England rarely meant what they said on the surface. They were coded commentary. Political satire disguised as children's songs. And this particular rhyme was a reference to one of the most significant political unions in British history.
England's Lion and Scotland's Unicorn
The lion has been a symbol of English royalty since the 12th century. Richard I (the Lionheart) adopted three golden lions on a red shield as his royal arms, and that imagery stuck. Bold, aggressive, dominant, and unapologetic about it. Very much on brand for a nation that spent most of its medieval history conquering things.
Scotland chose the unicorn. And that choice says a lot about how Scotland saw itself. In medieval heraldry, the unicorn was considered the natural enemy of the lion. It was wild, untamable, and fiercely independent. Nobody puts a leash on a unicorn. Scottish kings adopted it as their royal emblem as early as the 12th century, and by the 1400s it appeared on the Scottish Royal Coat of Arms.
Two neighboring kingdoms. Two proud symbols. One inevitable collision.
Centuries of Conflict Between England and Scotland
The rivalry between England and Scotland wasn't symbolic. It was real, brutal, and went on for hundreds of years.
The Wars of Scottish Independence (1296-1357) are probably the most famous chapter. Edward I of England, known charmingly as "the Hammer of the Scots," invaded Scotland in 1296 and stole the Stone of Destiny from Scone Abbey. William Wallace fought back. Robert the Bruce won at Bannockburn in 1314. The lion and the unicorn were, quite literally, fighting for the crown.
Find yours below
But the conflicts didn't stop there. Border skirmishes, raids, and full-scale invasions continued through the 14th, 15th, and 16th centuries. The Battle of Flodden in 1513 killed King James IV of Scotland and thousands of Scottish soldiers. The Battle of Solway Moss in 1542 was another English victory that contributed to the death of James V. Each generation added another chapter to the grudge.
Through all of this, both nations clung to their symbols. The lion and the unicorn weren't just decorative. They represented national identity and the refusal to submit. When you see them side by side today, you're looking at the visual record of a conflict that shaped the British Isles.
James I and the Union of the Crowns in 1603
Then something unexpected happened. Elizabeth I of England died in 1603 without an heir, and the English crown passed to James VI of Scotland. Overnight, the same person became king of both England and Scotland. James VI of Scotland became James I of England.
The lion and the unicorn finally had to share a coat of arms.
James created a new Royal Coat of Arms that combined both symbols. The English lion stood on the left (the position of honor in English heraldry). The Scottish unicorn stood on the right. They flanked a central shield topped by a crown, representing the united kingdom.
And here's the detail that still gets people talking: the unicorn is chained.
Why Is the Unicorn Chained on the Royal Coat of Arms?
If you look closely at the Royal Coat of Arms, you'll notice that the unicorn wears a crown around its neck with a chain trailing behind it. The lion stands free. This asymmetry has fueled debate for over 400 years.
The official explanation is rooted in medieval symbolism. In heraldic tradition, a unicorn was considered so powerful and dangerous that it could only be tamed by chaining it. The chain wasn't an insult. It was a mark of respect for the creature's strength. Unchained, a unicorn was too dangerous to control. The chain symbolized the raw power of this mythical creature being willingly harnessed in service of the crown.
But many Scots have interpreted it differently. To them, the chain represents England's dominance over Scotland. The lion stands free and proud. The unicorn is restrained. If you wanted a visual metaphor for a forced union, it'd be hard to do better than one partner standing unchained while the other wears a leash.
Interestingly, the Scottish version of the Royal Coat of Arms (used in Scotland to this day) reverses the positions. The unicorn gets the left side (the position of honor), and the lion moves to the right. Same symbols, same union, different emphasis. Scotland wasn't going to let England hog the prime real estate on their version.
So What Does the Nursery Rhyme Actually Mean?
Back to the rhyme. "The lion and the unicorn were fighting for the crown" is a direct reference to the centuries of Anglo-Scottish conflict. "The lion beat the unicorn all around the town" probably reflects the English perspective on the union, with England positioned as the dominant partner.
The bread and plum cake? Those lines likely refer to the public celebrations (or lack thereof) surrounding political events. In some interpretations, "drumming them out of town" refers to the displacement of one power by another.
Some historians date the rhyme to the Union of the Crowns in 1603. Others link it to the Acts of Union in 1707, when England and Scotland formally merged their parliaments. Either way, the sentiment is the same: two nations, two proud symbols, forced into an arrangement that one side felt more enthusiastic about than the other.
Lewis Carroll's Version in Through the Looking-Glass
The lion and the unicorn got a second life in 1871 when Lewis Carroll put them in Through the Looking-Glass. In Carroll's version, Alice encounters both creatures fighting in a town square, and they take a break from their brawl to eat bread and cake. The unicorn tells Alice he always believed children were "fabulous monsters," and Alice returns the compliment by saying she always thought unicorns were fabulous monsters too. They agree to believe in each other.
Carroll was doing what Carroll always did: taking something familiar and turning it absurd. But he kept the political undertones. His lion and unicorn are ridiculous, bickering figures who fight endlessly over nothing, stop for snacks, and then get drummed out of town. It's not hard to read that as satire of Anglo-Scottish politics. Or politics in general.
Pick your favorite
The illustrations by John Tenniel made the connection even more explicit. Tenniel drew the lion wearing a crown and the unicorn with a somewhat bewildered expression, echoing the heraldic imagery that every British reader would have recognized immediately.
The Lion and the Unicorn in Pubs and Culture
Walk through any older town in England or Scotland and you'll eventually pass a pub called The Lion and the Unicorn. Or The Unicorn. Or The Lion. These aren't random names. Pub naming in Britain has deep roots in heraldry and national symbolism, and the lion-unicorn pairing is one of the most popular.
The Lion and the Unicorn pub tradition dates back centuries. Inns and taverns often displayed the Royal Coat of Arms on their signs to show loyalty to the crown (and to indicate they had a royal license to serve). Over time, publicans started naming their establishments directly after the heraldic symbols.
You'll also find the lion and unicorn pairing on coins, government buildings, military insignia, and passport covers. The two creatures frame the entrances of courthouses and post offices across the UK. They're on the gates of Buckingham Palace. They're carved into stone on buildings that are older than most countries.
The Unicorn as Scotland's National Animal
Here's something that surprises a lot of people: Scotland's national animal is the unicorn. Not a real animal. A mythological creature. Scotland chose the unicorn and has stuck with that choice for centuries.
And it makes perfect sense. The unicorn in Celtic and Scottish tradition represented purity, innocence, power, and independence. These were values that Scotland fiercely identified with, especially during the centuries when English kings kept trying to absorb them. Choosing the unicorn was a statement: we are wild, we are proud, and good luck trying to make us kneel.
The Scottish use of the unicorn predates the union with England by hundreds of years. William I of Scotland used a unicorn on his seal in the 1100s. By the time James III put unicorns on gold coins in the 1400s, the association was firmly established. The unicorn wasn't borrowed from anyone. Scottish through and through.
Today, you'll see unicorns all over Scotland. On the Mercat Cross in Edinburgh. At the gates of the Palace of Holyroodhouse. On the Royal Mile. At Stirling Castle, where carved unicorns guard the Great Hall. These aren't cute decorations. They're symbols of national identity with nearly a millennium of history behind them.
What the Lion and the Unicorn Mean Today
The rivalry between the lion and the unicorn has softened considerably since the days of Bannockburn and Flodden. These days, the two symbols coexist on the Royal Coat of Arms more as a historical record than an active grievance. But the tension hasn't disappeared entirely. Scottish independence movements have occasionally used the chained unicorn as a metaphor for Scotland's position within the United Kingdom.
For unicorn lovers, though, the story offers something genuinely interesting. The unicorn as a mythological symbol isn't just about rainbows and sparkles (though we love those too). It's been a symbol of national identity and untamable defiance for nearly a thousand years. An entire country chose it as their defining emblem. That's pretty significant.
Next time you hear someone sing about the lion and the unicorn fighting for the crown, you'll know it's not really about two animals. It's about two nations, two identities, and one of the longest rivalries in European history. The plum cake is optional.
If you're drawn to the symbolism of unicorns and want something to celebrate that independent unicorn spirit, our unicorn jewelry collection has pieces inspired by heraldic and mythological designs. And for those who love adding unicorn magic to their space, our unicorn decorations range from regal to whimsical.
